4.9/5 · Published reviews
GPS Finance Group · EV finance comparison

Can a 12% novated lease beat a 0.09% car loan?

Compare a novated lease with a conventional car loan using after-tax costs and the full financing structure. A low advertised car-loan rate alone cannot capture GST, residual, running-cost and salary-packaging effects.

Compare the actual after-tax cost of owning an eligible electric vehicle. Change the salary, finance rates, GST treatment, running expenses and residual. See the interest rate at which a novated lease stops winning.

Novated leasing · Check your lease quote's rate

Your comparison

Preloaded with the illustrative Geely EX5 case study. Change any number. All amounts AUD.

Default from the case study. Check whether already included in the drive-away figure.
Some costs may be GST-free or ineligible.

Tax and lease assumptions

ATO minimum 36-month residual: 46.88%.
100% assumes the vehicle price is fully GST-creditable; drive-away costs may not be.
How to read this: This model compares both options on a common end-of-term ownership basis. It assumes no additional balloon on the car loan, no vehicle resale proceeds and the novated lease residual is paid personally at the end. It does not assume the social media post's tax saving is correct.
Estimated difference over the term
Calculating…
Car loan total—
Novated lease total—
Break-even novated lease interest rate
—

At this rate, the estimated total costs are equal, holding every other assumption constant.

Show the numbers

Car loan repayment / month
Car loan total including running costs and fees
Estimated GST-exclusive lease vehicle amount
Lease amount financed including added costs
Lease residual before GST
Lease residual paid incl. GST
Monthly lease rental (pre-tax, ex GST)
Monthly running costs packaged (ex eligible GST)
Total salary sacrificed over term
Total estimated income tax + Medicare saving
Total estimated after-tax salary sacrifice
End-of-term residual incl. GST

Compare a real novated lease quote →

Why a near-zero car loan rate does not settle the comparison

The comparison is between two total ownership costs, not the stated interest rates. The lease has a residual payment, but eligible electric car leases may have GST and income-tax benefits. The low-rate car loan is paid from after-tax income. We include equivalent running expenses on both sides.

What this calculator does

Loan repayments use standard monthly amortisation. Lease rentals use balloon amortisation, with the selected residual percentage of the GST-exclusive financed amount. We add the residual and GST at the end. For an eligible exempt EV, eligible packaged expenses reduce taxable salary. Tax savings are calculated as the difference between estimated annual tax at original salary and after salary sacrifice, including the low-income tax offset and a simplified Medicare levy calculation using the latest published 2025–26 single-person threshold.

What can change the result?

  • Actual vehicle pricing: GST savings cannot be inferred just by dividing an entire drive-away figure by 1.1; stamp duty, registration, insurance and some fees have different treatment. Check the quote's component prices.
  • Low-income thresholds: salary sacrifice can alter LITO and the Medicare levy. A flat 32% or 17% tax-saving assumption is unreliable.
  • FBT eligibility: the EV exemption depends on the vehicle and arrangement. If it does not apply, the displayed fully pre-tax lease result is not valid; obtain the employer contribution method before comparing.
  • HELP debt and other income tests: reportable fringe benefits can affect HELP repayment income and other entitlements. This model does not calculate those impacts.
  • Running expenses: the GST credit percentage is editable because insurance, registration and other expenses do not all carry identical GST treatment.

Frequently asked questions

Does a 12% lease always beat a 0.09% loan? No. Test the salary, residual, real GST-creditable vehicle amount, fees and tax treatment. Small savings can disappear when the actual quote is entered.

Is the residual an extra cost? Yes. To compare ownership at the end of the term, this calculator includes the amount payable to keep the car.

Should I compare monthly repayments only? No. Compare the total after-tax payments plus the ownership payout over the same period.

Source references

ATO: minimum residual values (TD 93/142) · ATO: resident tax rates · ATO: electric car exemption

Prepared by GPS Finance Group. Illustrative estimate using Australian resident 2026–27 income-tax brackets; excludes salary-linked deductions, other offsets, some Medicare exceptions, reportable fringe benefits effects and individual employer quote variations. Last reviewed 29 October 2026.

Worked example: why the advertised rate is only one input

Illustrative ordinary-loan payments, not a complete novated-lease cost comparison
Vehicle borrowing amount$60,000
Term5 years
Car loan at 0.09% p.a.$1,002.29/month
Car loan at 7.00% p.a.$1,188.07/month
Difference in scheduled monthly payments$185.78

A novated lease has different payroll, residual and tax mechanics; the two ordinary-loan payments above do not predict which structure is cheaper. Use the interactive comparison to model the complete structure.

Questions before you decide

Can a higher-rate novated lease beat a near-zero car loan?

It can under some input assumptions, but only the full after-tax comparison can establish that. GST treatment, fringe-benefit rules, residual, payroll deductions and running costs can outweigh a simple rate comparison.

Why must both structures use a matched horizon?

Comparing a lease over five years with a loan over another term misstates the relative cost. Include the residual or remaining vehicle value at the same endpoint.

Where should I decode the actual lease finance rate?

Use the Novated Lease Interest Rate Calculator and Quote Decoder to reverse-engineer the finance component in your supplied quotation. This page owns the structure-level comparison.

Analyse the after-tax cost and the residual, not just the salary deduction

A novated lease packages a vehicle finance contract with employer payroll arrangements. The contracted finance rental, running-cost budget, GST treatment and tax effects are distinct parts of the quote.

Compare finance cost and expected cash-flow cost separately. EV FBT treatment, employee contributions, the vehicle's eligible status and the lease term can make two otherwise similar offers produce very different take-home-pay outcomes.

Build the end-of-term residual into the ownership decision. A small per-pay deduction does not establish that the vehicle is cheaper to own after residual, operating costs and any fees are considered.

Compare the numbers

Analyse the after-tax cost and the residual, not just the salary deduction — illustrative comparison
Illustrative $60,000 finance basisAmount
Example term60 months
Illustrative residual at 28.13%$16,878
Amount of principal before finance charges$60,000
Residual still due at maturity$16,878

This is a residual exposure demonstration, not a lease rental, tax outcome or implied rate. Use the quote decoder with actual rental, term, GST treatment, financed amount and residual.

What changes the decision?

  • Keep the finance rental separate from the payroll deduction.
  • Use the vehicle's eligibility and salary position when assessing tax effects.
  • Include the residual and likely vehicle value at the intended exit.

How the choice changes in real borrowing situations

FBT-exempt eligible electric vehicle

A qualifying EV may produce a different after-tax outcome from a conventional vehicle, but the underlying lease cost, residual, statutory eligibility and reporting arrangements still matter. Compare complete cash flows instead of relying on a tax label.

Plug-in hybrid or conventional vehicle

FBT outcomes can differ by vehicle class and commencement dates, including transitional arrangements. Use the exact vehicle and contract context to determine assumptions instead of applying the same effective payroll benefit to every quote.

Early departure from employer

Changing employer or ending salary packaging can affect the novation and responsibility for the lease. Compare exit requirements and the lease payout with the expected employment horizon.

End-of-term trade-in

The residual is a contractual amount, while the market value is uncertain. Test positive and negative equity at maturity before assuming trade-in proceeds will settle the lease.

Research reference: View the original guidance.

Questions behind this decision

These are labelled paraphrases of questions or guidance published at the linked source, not customer testimonials.

Do salary-packaging savings outweigh the true car-finance cost?

The ATO describes novated lease rental, residual and employer fringe-benefit obligations; compare the full after-tax structure rather than only the finance rate.

How this calculator helps: Compare all three structures over the same term with residual and running costs.

Official Australian guidance: Read original source

What if the employer's advertised savings do not become take-home pay?

The ATO separates lease costs and fringe-benefit tax outcomes, making it necessary to distinguish the financial commitment from the payroll effect.

How this calculator helps: Separate cashflow, packaged benefits, finance rentals and tax outcomes.

Official Australian guidance: Read original source

How do I infer a finance rate from a novated quote's residual and fortnightly rental?

The ATO identifies lease payments, interest and residual value as components of car leasing; the implied rate should be decoded from the contractual rental rather than the net pay deduction.

How this calculator helps: Compare the full novated structure here, then follow the linked quote decoder to determine the contractual implied rate.

Official Australian guidance: Read original source

How does an eligible EV change novated-lease tax treatment?

ATO guidance describes the FBT exemption for eligible electric cars and associated expenses under stated conditions.

How this calculator helps: Compare EV eligibility and after-tax payroll effects separately from the financing rate.

Official Australian guidance: Read original source

Browse all finance calculators