New-Build Investment Property: Solving a Valuation Shortfall After the 2026 Tax Changes

By Krish Neelamraju

A Melbourne couple switched to a new-build investment after the 2026 negative gearing changes, then hit a valuation shortfall. Here's how it was resolved.

Want to explore your finance options?

Tell us what you need and we can help identify suitable lenders and next steps.

See my options →

Quick answer: After the 2026 Budget changes restricted negative gearing on established homes bought after 12 May 2026, a Melbourne couple chose a newly built townhouse instead. The bank's valuation came in $35,000 under the contract price. They negotiated the price down using the valuation, released equity from their home for the deposit, and kept the two loans uncrossed.

  • Finance: Investment loan $534,400 (80% of $668,000 valuation) + $180,000 equity release on home
  • Main obstacle: First valuation $655,000 against a $690,000 contract
  • What worked: Standalone securities (not crossed); home LVR about 56%
  • Outcome: Approved after a revised price and second valuation; settled on time

At a glance

Borrowers Couple, aged 41 and 39, two children — project manager and part-time teacher
Location Investment in Tarneit, VIC; home in Reservoir, VIC
Property Newly completed townhouse; contract $690,000, renegotiated to $675,000
Loans Investment loan $534,400 (80% of $668,000 valuation) + $180,000 equity release on home
Main obstacle First valuation $655,000 against a $690,000 contract
Structure Standalone securities (not crossed); home LVR about 56%
Outcome Approved after a revised price and second valuation; settled on time

Who this case may apply to

  • Couple, aged 41 and 39, two children — project manager and part-time teacher may recognise a similar finance situation.
  • Borrowers in Investment in Tarneit, VIC; home in Reservoir, VIC considering residential investment property loans may find this case relevant.
  • Applicants facing a similar obstacle (First valuation $655,000 against a $690,000 contract) may find the example relevant.

What were the borrowers trying to do?

The couple owned their home (worth about $1.25 million, with $520,000 owing) and earned $237,000 between them. In April 2026 they were pre-approved to buy an established house as an investment. After Budget night, their accountant pointed out that rental losses on established homes bought after 7:30pm on 12 May 2026 can't be offset against salary from 1 July 2027, while new builds keep the existing treatment. They switched to a newly completed townhouse.

Why didn't the first option work?

The bank's valuer assessed the townhouse at $655,000, well under the $690,000 contract. A gap between the price and the valuation is common with new stock. At 80% of $655,000 the loan would have been $35,000 short of plan, and the bank also proposed taking both properties as security for the whole debt.

How was the application structured?

  1. Price renegotiation. The developer agreed to reduce the price to $675,000 once shown the valuation and recent resales in the estate.
  2. Second valuation. A different lender's panel valued the townhouse at $668,000.
  3. Separate securities. An equity loan of $180,000 on the home funded the deposit, duty and costs. A new $534,400 investment loan was secured by the townhouse alone.
  4. Tax check. Their accountant confirmed the property met the new-build definition before they signed the variation.

What evidence supported the application?

Evidence Why it mattered
Valuation report and estate resale data Justified the price reduction
Builder's completion documents and occupancy certificate Confirmed the home was new and complete
Rental appraisal ($550 a week) Supported the serviceability calculation
Payslips, home loan statements and living expenses Full-doc serviceability
Accountant's note on the new-build treatment Supported the investment rationale

What was the outcome?

Both loans were approved within 10 business days of the second valuation. Total debt of about $1.23 million against household income including rent of roughly $266,000 put their debt-to-income ratio well below 6, the threshold for APRA's limit on high-DTI lending. Both properties keep separate loans, which gives them more flexibility if they sell either one later.

What would have changed the result?

The result would likely have been different if the developer had refused to move on price and the second valuation had matched the first. A lower rental appraisal or higher household spending would also have weakened serviceability, as would an off-the-plan contract that wasn't yet complete.

What this case does — and does not — show

It shows that tax rules now influence what investors buy, and that new-build valuations need planning. It does not show that new builds are always the better investment. Tax treatment is only one factor.

Frequently asked questions

Do the 2026 negative gearing changes affect new builds?

Under the 2026 legislation, newly built residential property keeps access to negative gearing. The restriction targets established homes bought after 7:30pm AEST on 12 May 2026, with effect from 1 July 2027. Confirm your situation with your accountant.

What happens if a valuation comes in below the purchase price?

The lender lends against the lower figure, so you either contribute more, negotiate the price, or seek another valuation where that is appropriate.

Why avoid cross-collateralising investment properties?

Keeping each property as security for its own loan can make it simpler to sell, refinance or release equity from one property without involving the other.

Sources

  • APRA — DTI limit implementation details: https://www.apra.gov.au/sites/default/files/2025-11/Implementation%20Details%20-%20DTI%20limit.pdf
  • Moneysmart — Home loans: https://moneysmart.gov.au/home-loans

Related reading

Buying an investment property under the new rules? Talk to GPS Finance about structure before you sign.

Button 1: Check my options · Button 2: Ask a question

Written by: Krish Neelamraju. Last reviewed: 16 November 2026.

Want to explore your finance options?

Tell us what you need and we can help identify suitable lenders and next steps.

See my options →

← Previous post Next post →